White Sox Overpay Dustin May as MLB’s Spending Problem Grows

The Chicago White Sox flamed out of the playoffs after gaining a 2-0 series lead over the Cleveland Guardians. They controlled the game, leaning on their bullpen to carry them through much of the first two games in Cleveland.
When the series shifted back home to Chicago, something changed for the White Sox. Their method of attacking Cleveland with hundreds of arms wasn’t working anymore. After two games of Wild Card baseball and two more in the divisional series, Chicago’s bullpen seemed to be running on fumes. Postseason baseball is nothing like the regular season. Each pitch means so much more, and in turn, makes it significantly harder for players to bounce back as quickly.
They knew heading into this offseason they needed to improve pitching depth if they wanted their fun surprise run in 2026 to continue for years to come. Well, the White Sox made one of the first big moves of the offseason, signing 29-year-old Dustin May to a 3-year, $52.5 million dollar contract.
The often-injured May was the healthiest of his career in 2026, posting a career high in games started; however, that’s about where the compliments for May end. At his best, May is a big, hard-throwing righty who strikes out a ton of batters while not allowing many free passes.
But his body has betrayed him to some extent, and while he still throws with above-average velocity, it’s no longer something he can rely on consistently to blow by hitters. He got hit harder than most players in the sport last year, and on top of that, he wasn’t making hitters miss anymore. You won’t find a ton of success as a starter who doesn’t make people miss and gives up a ton of loud contact.
That’s why this contract feels like a scary precedent. With a lockout and potential cap looming large, teams might be willing to overpay a player to sign them before new rules are implemented.
Last season, May was outside the 50 highest-paid starting pitchers in the league. He followed that up with a 0.4 WAR, 85 ERA+ season, and is now the 40th highest-paid starting pitcher in the league. If people can’t see that this model for evaluating talent is broken and that a lockout is necessary, I don’t know what else will convince you.
Teams feel the need to overpay for washed players and pray one of them can find some part of their old selves, just to have a chance against the other big spenders. Yes, a team like the Brewers still can win, but they’re an outlier, not the rule. This feels like a horrible move for the White Sox, and it’s a move the rest of the starting pitchers looking to get paid will use to make even more money this offseason.
